October 20, 2025, 11:55 am | Read time: 3 minutes
Cordless screwdrivers are indispensable in the DIY world. They simplify numerous tasks and are available in many variations. The market offers a wide range of models for different needs and budgets. A recent comparison shows which devices excelled in power, endurance, and handling.
Whether it’s assembling shelves or building a terrace, a reliable cordless screwdriver is essential for many projects. However, the selection is vast, and not every model lives up to its promises. In an extensive test by COMPUTER BILD (part of Axel Springer, like myHOMEBOOK), traditional and compact cordless screwdrivers were tested under realistic conditions. Criteria such as screw power, ergonomics, and battery life were the focus.
Differences in Design and Application
The tested models can be divided into two groups: nine traditional cordless screwdrivers with up to 18 volts for universal use and three compact mini screwdrivers for smaller tasks. While the larger devices are suitable for more demanding jobs, the smaller models offer advantages in tight spaces.
The Test Winner: Metabo PowerMaxx BS 12
With a test score of 1.7, the Metabo PowerMaxx BS 12 secured the top spot. Despite slightly lower power, it impressed in almost all areas: precise speed control, removable chuck, long battery life, and solid construction. Particularly practical: Bits can be inserted directly behind the chuck—ideal for tight spots. The battery system is also flexible, as it is used by other manufacturers. A quick-release is missing, but the device is fairly priced at around 100 euros.
Powerhouse in Second Place: DeWalt DCD701D2
The DeWalt DCD701D2 took second place with a test score of 1.9, mainly due to its high screw power. With a robust 15.1 Newton meters, it effortlessly drove long screws into hardwood—a top value in the comparison test. The equipment is high-quality: two batteries, a sturdy transport box, and short charging times make the model appealing for more demanding DIY tasks. Minor weaknesses in ergonomics and comfort prevented a test win, but no other screwdriver outperformed it in terms of power.
Makita Model is Ergonomic and Powerful
Third place in the test went to the Makita DF333DSAE with a score of 2.2. Its strengths lie mainly in comfortable handling, precise speed control, and high power reserves. It’s well-suited for regular DIY tasks, even though a motor shutdown in case of overload is missing. The Makita battery system also stood out positively: It’s compatible with many of the manufacturer’s devices, saving additional batteries or chargers.
Other Models in the Test
The test field also included devices from Bosch, Black & Decker, Ikea, Worx, and other manufacturers. They ranged from very powerful models to weaker devices like the Bosch EasyDrill 12 (score 4.0), which is only suitable for simple tasks. Mini screwdrivers like the Bosch IXO VI were also tested—they are practical for smaller tasks but not full-fledged replacement devices.
Sanding with a Cordless Drill? This Tool Makes It Possible
The Best Multi-Tools in the 2025 Test
Differences in Charging Time and Equipment
There were also significant differences in charging speed. The Makita model charges particularly quickly, ready in just 30 minutes. Other devices took up to four hours. Differences were also evident in equipment: Only a few models have a battery status indicator or quick-change systems for bits.
How the Test Was Conducted
The cordless screwdrivers were tested both in the lab and under real conditions in a workshop. They had to drive over 3,600 Spax screws into spruce wood. Screw power, battery life, and charging time were measured. A special system recorded power and torque precisely, and factors like handling, ergonomics, and overload protection were included in the evaluation. All test results were cleaned and verified multiple times to provide objective and understandable results.